I. A Historical Echo: The 1929 Crash and the 2026 AI Wave
Professor James K. Galbraith of the University of Texas argues that—based on his theory regarding the true root causes of the 1929 Wall Street Crash and the ensuing Great Depression—the 2026 AI tech wave is stepping on the same historical rhymes.
First, he lists the complex and conflicting theories the economic community has proposed over the past century to explain these events. Examples include Hyman Minsky’s “Financial Instability Hypothesis" (capitalism is inherently fragile); William K. Black’s “Controlled Fraud" (deregulation allowing insider profit); John Maynard Keynes, who blamed the collapse of businessmen’s profit expectations driven by “animal spirits"; Milton Friedman and Anna Schwartz, who blamed the Fed for failing to stop the money supply contraction; Ben Bernanke and Christina Romer, emphasizing the spike in market uncertainty; or Larry Summers, who vaguely attributed the crisis to a “failure of exchange mechanisms."
Galbraith, however, argues that the real trigger for the 1929 crash was a disruptive energy technology revolution. In the early 20th century, the physical economy and financial assets of the US were heavily dependent on coal, steam engines, steel, and a massive cross-state railroad network. However, in late October 1929, Texas, Oklahoma, and California successively announced the discovery of massive oil reserves. Media reports detailed how Standard Oil was slashing prices due to overproduction and cutting inventory.
Why did the discovery of massive, cheap, high-quality energy not bring the expected economic prosperity, but unexpectedly trigger billions in financial losses, evolving into historical “Black Thursday" and “Black Tuesday"? The answer lies in the fact that financial market pricing reflects the future profit expectations of the “existing industrial system." At the time, banks held massive assets in coal and railroad bonds, while corporate profits relied on the rail transport network and coal power systems. The oil discoveries meant that these heavy-asset investments faced unannounced obsolescence. Expected profits hit zero overnight. Companies stopped capital investment, prices for agricultural and industrial goods collapsed, banks couldn’t recover loans (encountering bank runs), and the real economy suffered a chain reaction collapse—the Great Depression began.
Galbraith points out that if today’s AI technology represents an industrial-revolution-level advancement, it could very well repeat the depression of 1929.
To simplify this with my own understanding:
From an economic perspective, competition forces many industries impacted by AI to lower their profit expectations, thereby reducing asset prices. If these asset prices (whether tangible property, land, factories, machinery, or intangible property such as intellectual property, corporate bonds, and stocks) are interwoven into a complex financial market via collateral and borrowing, it forces a downward revision of even more complex financial derivatives based on them (such as credit swaps). This asset price correction strengthens negative macro expectations and alters economic behavior, creating a negative feedback loop deflation similar to 1929 or 2008.
On the other hand, can the actual income growth generated by new AI technology catch up with the hyped revenue bubbles? If releasing data convinces more people that growth speed cannot keep pace, combined with a worsening objective interest rate environment, the AI bubble will burst. Since mid-year, borrowing rates and the difficulty of borrowing for AI-related companies—especially in the “neo-cloud" sector—have risen sharply. Viewing this as a risk premium indicates that more and more in the market are losing confidence.
II. The Conspiracy of China-US AI Competition
I believe this conspiracy theory has low credibility, but it is interesting.
According to clearer data over recent months, we can see that the actual income growth from the AI tech revolution is far below the “castles in the air" drawn by its promoters.
The conspiracy theory suggests this is why the Chinese government has not truly expended “all resources" on the “US-China AI competition." Instead, China is applying and developing AI tech mainly based on its own domestic industrial environment and needs.
In the AI competition, China maintains a pace of “just about catching up to the US" to tempt and frighten US politicians, and provide industry justifications, to deploy vast amounts of US national resources into developing LLMs—which actually offer low returns.
In short, China is tempting the US to fall into the “Star Wars" trap that the Soviet Union fell into decades ago.
The above are two considerations regarding AI for everyone’s reference.